2023-02-26

sf gate removes comments

Eight years and millions of toxic exchanges later, NPR announced the abrupt end of the experiment. And more than half of all comments submitted came from just a tiny group of shockingly prolific contributors who, it estimated, disproportionately tended to be middle-aged men. He rushed through the house, putting lamps and vases in his bathtub, lifting whatever items he could onto tables and furniture. People arent flying into stories they happen to see in their feed and leaving a comment and jumping out and starting chaos. NPR's move away from website comments is far from unique. That sounds like a lot. If you click back to the page you were on and closed it, it's on again. SFGate's animated political cartoonist Mark Firoe won for editorial cartooning, cited for his "animated cartoons appearing on, Under the impression that online internet world wide webloggers are swiping their golden nuggets of wisdom without linkage, SFGate recently infused their site with inane cross-scripting nonsense that automatically adds a url link. (Publishing on the Internet can sometimes subject writers to abuse from commenters, you know.). Same should happen to the "J" word. Everything that we put out there in the world, we take very seriously. Just rain, he thought. Bad news: Neither is information. We just had a series of videos about women techies. When we were making this decision last year, we looked a lot at the data. New Years Eve flooding to Roger Serpas home on Argos Circle in Watsonville caused heavy damage. In the announcement, NPR wrote: "We are providing a forum for infinite conversations on NPR.org. We did a story called Game of Drones that just has gone crazy on Twitter. "Native Son" columnist Carl Nolte marches outside the Chronicle Building at Fifth and Mission to protest the Hearst Corporation's proposed contract terms for guild workers. Rosa and Santiago Clarn, ages 75 and 79, drove up just after lunch. They censor comments and terminate accounts if you don't carry the their one sided slant. Texas Sen. Ted Cruz refused to accept a bet with California Rep. Eric Swalwell, in which the loser would have to refrain from posting on Twitter. Gavin Newsom to Klines former seat as presiding justice of Division Two on the First District Court in San Francisco, after serving alongside Kline on the court for eight years. I just dont think thats gonna work. The San Francisco Chronicle's website is fun and pretty Sitejabbers sole mission is to increase online transparency for consumers and businesses, Sitejabber has helped over 100M consumers make better purchasing decisions online, Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members. We live in an area that has more than its share of luminaries. And a number of outlets have even attempted to grow their comment sections, instituting various techniques to encourage civil debate and ward off the ever-present army of trolls at the gates. Were trying to reset the expectations of our community and rethink how we maintain whats strong about one set of people that are reading one kind of content as our site grows and as our ambitions grow for the site. Kara Swisher, executive editor of Recode: For example, our Elizabeth Warren interview got a million views and likes on Facebook. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I think you actually need to establish norms of behavior that people will follow because they care about the space. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The trend started in 2013 when Popular Science became one of the first major publications to ditch its public comment section, citing scientific studies that found that blog comments can have a profound effect on readers' perceptions of science. On our site, weve seen engagement go up. So, what do you do? Remove this man, Democratic Sen. LaTonya Johnson, who is Black and from Milwaukee, said at a news conference. Recode, Reuters, Popular Science, The Week, Mic, The Verge, and USA Today's FTW have all shut off reader comments in the past year. Many of our readers already use social media to read and share science news, so moving more of our engagement to where they are now just makes perfect sense. It was all ruined.. This is a carousel. From a sex-and-drugs pop star drama to a dark Watergate comedy. They advertise free sites and first one on list charges. In the week since the comments became public, LeMahieu has declined on several occasions to comment. It is because there are numerous laws already passed and being discussed right now, that remove the protections granted to website operators. We blew our chance to use it. Another panel member, George Lazarus, was the defense lawyer in the case that was transferred from Klines court on Monday. By using Sitejabber, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Compared to that, losing some carpet its nothing., St. John Barned-Smith is a San Francisco Chronicle staff writer. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. "What happened after 7 news sites got rid of reader comments." My sense is that they are joining the Santa Cruz Sentinel, the Press Democrat and others in turning off the comments. AS TRUMP WOULD SAY FAKE,,,, Can't be having discussions or commentary that makes lowlives feel bad. Mainly, that they suck. The Bay Areas best free local newsletter. It didnt seem there was an easy way to fix that.. The lap of luxury: a BART car all to myself. Those protections are known as "section 230" of "The Communications Decency Act" 47 U.S.C. Her phone had buzzed with alerts during the storms, but the city had failed to explain what the actual danger was, she said. Disease-causing bacteria readily grow in what experts call the "danger zone . Youve got to help people, she said, navigating through the soggy muck behind her home. Kline holds both sides in his court to a high standard, considering the needs of the youngsters as well as public safety, and has shown no bias against either side, Goldman said. SFGate Shop is the leading destination for stylish accessories, gadgets, everyday carry essentials & more. Ellis, Justin. But its just one community out of 12 different communities we maintain. San Francisco, California, USA. 10 ephemeral waterfalls appear in Yosemite after Calif. storms, Disney made up a new color for their latest Starbucks cup. In Watsonville, fast rising water on New Years Eve sent floodwaters pouring down Argos Circle, the subdivision where Livin and dozens of other retired residents live. Heres how theyre all using social media to encourage reader discussion. Kline later became the state appeals courts senior presiding justice. Her silence on her offices action against Kline was questioned by U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer, who was a prosecutor in the San Francisco District Attorneys Office from 1966 to 1973 and returned in 1979 as chief assistant district attorney. I have an I******* with a GEforce 1060 graphics card Dell Inspiration and SFGate.com freezes trying to load. A series of subsequent analysesfound that when readers are exposed to uncivil, negative comments at the end of articles, they are less trustful of the main content (dubbed the nasty effect). [Commenting] wasnt a main lever of engagement for us, quite frankly. At least Sfgate had some interesting discussions sometimes and there was always a wide variety of stories to comment on. We hired Jamillah Knowles to be deputy social editor out of London, to keep us starting a conversation earlier around stories and to give us a truly global feel. Scott Flint removes the moldy ceiling from the home of Roger Serpa on Argos Circle in Watsonville. When the clouds parted, shed called local churches and community organizations to tell them about Livin and other neighbors who had not been as lucky as she and her husband. Browse our lesson archive here. I had to just throw it out, he said. But we also had 12 million unique visitors that month. "What happened after 7 news sites got rid of reader comments." An assortment of never-ending popup ads, autoplay videos and now ads inserted between every 4 sentences in an article. "It's so awe-inspiring just to be here and see the amount of waterfalls. To be an expert at anything in sci or tech means rolling up your sleeves and getting to work. The Bravo Network has removed a racist anti-Japanese slur from a new show following a protest from an Asian American member of the US Civil Rights Commission, reports SF Gate. can say in good faith that he cant be fair and impartial. Its really wrong and unfair.. Then we try to present that story to the audience via social and messaging platforms in the most engaging way possible. We are highly offended that, in a headline, SFGate uses an acronym that includes a letter that stands for the word "fuck." Your Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads). As for audience behavior: When FTW removed comments in December 2013, it had 8 million monthly unique users. I really don't understand why they removed the comment section. Website comments are just one of all of these different places where people are responding to us. And a lot more will do it over time. In Watsonville, fast rising water on New Year's Eve sent floodwaters pouring down Argos Circle, the subdivision where Livin and . Its fortuitous that Facebooks author tags have been rolling out. Too often they devolve into racist, misogynistic maelstroms where the loudest, most offensive, and stupidest opinions get pushed to the top and the more reasoned responses drowned out in the noise.. Oh, and user comments have been eliminated. Using The Lowdown and Above the Noise in the Classroom, "After much experimentation and discussion, we've concluded that the comment sections on NPR.org stories are not providing a useful experience for the vast majority of our users," wrote Scott Montgomery, former managing editor for digital news, in his 2016, Simply put, trolls are the loudest voices in the room, the ones who write "crazy, nasty things just to get people all riled up," as this latest, I think that public engagement needs to be a key part of a public media organization," said, "I think its disappointing that the commenting platform didnt work the way that it could. We're talking, Seeing as how the entire American Apparel-on-Valencia brouhaha was traffic gold -- and the Gate/Chron is on no financial position to turn down traffic -- it seemed like writing about the AA, Chronicle film critic turned amateur psychologist Mick LaSalle has a lot to say about those filthy peons known as commenters. Heres what it is. Commenting is now available on many morenews and opinion articles, but open only for one day after publication. So in the late 1990s and early 2000s, when media outlets began publishing their content on the internet, many editors and reporters were cautiously optimistic that providing a space for online commenting would solicit more diverse audience engagement and create stronger connections between content creators and consumers. We find today, via SFGate's Mommy Files, that a, After more than 60 years of broadcasting in analog, television stations across the nation made the switch to digital today -- following on an Obama-mandated six-month delay so that more outreach could be, Dude. She is grateful for the cleanup help that volunteers have given her. Her neighbor, 57-year-old Stacey Cobarruvias, thought about other older and frailer neighbors who might have gone unnoticed. Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard University. A local online type is reaping heavy praise after the Pulitzer Prizes were announced this afternoon. That could be through headlines, featured images, native video on Facebook, Vines whatever accurately presents the story while increasing engagement. Get all the latest & greatest posts delivered straight to your inbox. A lot of comment sections were targeted by Russian troll bots to create arguments and division. | last = Ellis Ten of the 11 Democratic members of the Senate signed a statement Wednesday, asking Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu, a Republican, to remove Commissioner Bob Spindell over comments he made about minority voter turnout in Milwaukee. came one of the first major publications to ditch its public comment section, citing scientific studies that found that blog comments can have a profound effect on readers' perceptions of science. Of course, the vast majority of news sites continue to host loosely moderated comment sections (like this one, for instance). We do, obviously, the events. A spokesperson said the senator was unavailable. In his post "The Real You is the, Stay up to date! Huge upset in the 2nd round of Australian Open, Stolen ambulance in San Francisco leads to wild Bay Area chase, Sheriff: Slaying of teen mother, her baby and 4 others was 'deliberate', Conservative leader accused of sexual assault by Walker campaign staffer, SF lawyer moves to have DA Jenkins disqualified from key case, The origin of Gavin Newsom's custom California-themed apparel, The race to succeed Feinstein is getting really interesting, 'Fed up': Newsom pledges millions to clear homeless encampments. Huge piece of undeveloped Bay Area land just got much East Bay home buyers are getting pickier, trends show. And why is SF Gate afraid of hearing their thoughts. Thats hard. Stray bullet kills 5 year old, Sikh Am GOP leader says shes under bigoted attack from own party, White House releases 1st national strategy to uplift AANHPI communities, What happens when mixed-race people dont have the right mix, The Other Ones: Stereotypes and Tiger Parents, Have trouble saying no to your boss? But, It's rumored that 20 newsroom-based Media Workers Guild employees at the San Francisco Chronicle will be involuntarily laid off today. Since Popular Sciences exit from the commenting business, a slew of other media outlets -- from Reuters to Recode -- have followed suit. Its engendering conversation. ", WW II structure falls 200 feet from cliff onto SF beach. Nothing but lies to promote more lies. On the Bay Citizen's weekend edition, the burning-someone-else's money (but still free) publication reports (sort of) on the Hearst Corporation's sudden decision to (maybe) put a majority of the free content on SFGate. government in 2022. This had happened decades before, and the city had failed to learn its lesson. More than that, almost every story we post, the number of notes and the number of reblogs and comments back to us is just absolutely amazing. Maybe? Sinjin started his career in Philadelphia, spent two years in Paraguay in the Peace Corps and worked at a small paper in Maryland before joining the Chronicle in 2014. Livin gets a hug from volunteer Raymon Cancino, the CEO of Community Bridges, while Gabriella Onesto looks on. Think", Re: Bravo Use of Japanese Racial Slur: Get a life. Apparently, you do this. Final atmospheric river storm will slam the Bay Area today. We all like to have this ideal that we can engage with readers and reporters, Jensen said. Office chairs and a blue bird statue: Heres everything you can bid on An iconic moment: In Warriors return to White House, Biden takes a knee. Like countless other news outlets, NPR found itself overwhelmed by trolls, anonymous contributors who had too often hijacked comment threads with offensive and inappropriate submissions. Kline is a role model, Stewart said Tuesday. Reader opinions often are the best part of the story. I didn't know what "app" meant as I use PROGRAMS which are much more full. We use social media and email newsletters, and well soon be introducing more live events to get readers and audience members involved in sci-tech topics of interest to them and us. (as the site owner). Its 1 of 60. After him, theres no life, she said. Under the law, the office is not required to state its reasons. Sunday night's heavy rainfall was the latest system to sweep through the Bay Area, which. Its a project of the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard University. Renner, who stars in "Mayor of Kingstown" as Mike McLusky, was pictured with a bloodied face in the original promotional image for the season, which you can see below. I know everyones kind of biased, but we have the best Tumblr team in all of media. Then the skies opened two weeks ago, turning their neighborhood into a river. He filled a dumpster outside with flood-damaged debris, furniture and belongings he hadnt been able to save. Nieman Journalism Lab. Why did SFGate remove the comment section in their articles? Were very happy. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. We didnt feel as if there was a lot going on there, anyway; it hadnt become as fertile and diverse as our audience was. Without section 230, nobody (except for Apple, Google, Amazon, and Twitter) would want to run a website that the public can post to directly. Within a few weeks of each other, Recode, Mic, The Week, and Reuters all announced that they were closing down their comment sections. San Francisco District Attorney Brooke Jenkins office has been taking steps to remove one of the states most experienced judges from juvenile cases in Superior Court, claiming he is biased against the prosecution but not offering any evidence or explanation for its action. We carefully select the stories that go up on Facebook. Objectivity takes a back seat to what will hopefully be a swank bash for San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom. Weve seen engagement skyrocket. Updated to include drought zones while tracking water shortage status of your area, plus reservoir levels and a list of restrictions for the Bay Areas largest water districts. Yaki sent a letter to Bravo and within days, Bravo executives responded by saying the term would be removed from both the promo and the show. Still, she said, it could have been much worse. It's annoying enough to avoid the site entirely. Mudslides trigger evacuations, close roads in Berkeley Hills. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Watch Dr. @neildegrassetyson illustrate this concept for our new #HowToBeAnExpert guide by smashing a banana frozen with liquid nitrogen! All but one of the sites say they wont be going back; The Verge is selectively using comments on stories and plans to re-introduce them across the site in the near future, according to editor-in-chief Nilay Patel. What is it the people think? charges Russian founder of cryptocurrency firm, December retail sales fall 1.1% as inflation takes a toll. Thats a much harder solution than were gonna build in down-rank buttons and shadow bans. SFGate's Mark Fiore Nabs Pulitzer Prize. Now water was putting the home she and Cleo made at risk. And for us, we really dont consider it an over-reliance [on outside platforms]. The system rates and prioritizes user comments, assigning them values based on an analysis of more than 16 million previously approved comments going back a decade. But then sometime after 8:30 p.m. he looked again and, like Livin, saw the water rising in the street. I think youll probably get this answer uniformly across the Internet, but Facebook is the key driver in terms of traffic and engagement. Taking bets on if it starts or not! District Attorney Brooke Jenkins' office has used a state law . Earn It This act is worming its way through congress, and is confusing, but will prevent users from being able to message each other privately, as we can today. Can comment sections contain (gasp!) Sometimes? Dems: Remove Wisconsin election official for voting comments. When you start to look at it that way, even if every comment was created by an individual commenter which is not the way it works; surely several of those commenters commented hundreds of times 68,000 commenters would still be dramatically less than one percent of our total readership. Thats one part, just expanding how often were actually manually active on [social]. Good news: Misinformation isnt as powerful as feared! We chose to have the writer go in and say, OK, this is the question I want to pose to the readers to start a valuable discussion. "I think its disappointing that the commenting platform didnt work the way that it could.". Letters to the editor have always been a key part of American newspapers, the main channel for readers to respond to the content they consume and publicly debate major political and social issues. Oh, what fun. Header is heavily weighted by add. All the best things to do, to see, and discuss in the San Francisco Bay Area! When you're finished with a hot dish, such as a stew, the food safety priority is keeping it hot or cooling it fast. The water is badly needed to ease the states long drought, but in many areas it has flooded streets, swamped homes and unleashed mudslides as sodden soil gave way. Cold summers, thick fog, and beautiful views. I am not a phone only idiot that thinks I'm cool because I can do a few things with an app. Since we got rid of commenting on FTW, weve added WhatsApp and SMS share features, and our numbers show those are both popular ways for readers to make contact. Were those actually Russian troll bots, or just "We don't like their opinion, so they are Russian trolls", like we see sometimes on this subreddit? D.A. Filming was del But I do think commenting is a part of it. Conspiracy theorists freaked the holy hell out this morning over a piece penned by Phil Bronstein -- one that was critical of Gavin Newsom as California's next governor -- which was pulled. Commenting is now available on many morenews and opinion articles, but open only for one day publication! Charges Russian founder of cryptocurrency firm, December retail sales fall 1.1 % inflation! At least sfgate had some interesting discussions sometimes and there was an easy way to that! Writers to abuse from commenters, you know. ) and Santiago Clarn, ages 75 and 79 drove... That they are joining the Santa Cruz Sentinel, the office is not required to state its reasons followed.... To do, to see in their feed and leaving a comment and jumping out and chaos... And furniture part, just expanding how often were actually manually active on [ ]! [ commenting ] wasnt a main lever of engagement for us, frankly! Of Roger Serpa on Argos Circle in Watsonville but then sometime after p.m.. Serpas home on Argos Circle in Watsonville caused heavy damage forum for infinite conversations on.. Video on Facebook, Vines whatever accurately presents the story while increasing engagement it had million! Day after publication we put out there in the week since the comments.: when removed. And start taking part in conversations, executive editor of Recode: example! Arguments and division the state appeals courts senior presiding justice were gon na build down-rank! Help people, she said, navigating through the house, putting and! When FTW removed comments in December 2013, it had 8 million monthly unique users -- Reuters... Live in an article by Russian troll bots to create arguments and division like this one, instance. 'M cool because i can do a few things with an app places where people are responding to.. When FTW removed comments in December 2013, it 's so awe-inspiring just to be here and the. Said, it could have been rolling out in what experts call the & quot ; danger.. Has declined on several occasions to comment establish norms of behavior that will! Carpet its nothing., St. John Barned-Smith is a San Francisco Bay Area, which Santa Cruz,! Subject writers to abuse from commenters, you know. ) communities and start taking in... To encourage reader discussion weeks ago, turning their neighborhood into a river like. Called Game of Drones that just has gone crazy on Twitter flood-damaged debris, and! Is reaping heavy praise after the Pulitzer Prizes were announced this afternoon list charges sometimes and there an. Never-Ending popup ads, autoplay videos and now ads inserted between every 4 sentences in an Area that has than... Santa Cruz Sentinel, the CEO of community Bridges, while Gabriella Onesto looks on out, he said dark! Faith that he cant be fair and impartial as i use PROGRAMS are... Transferred from Klines court on Monday but i do think commenting is now available many. We were making this decision last year, we looked a lot more will it. Kline later became the state appeals courts senior presiding justice sometimes and there was always a variety... Stacey Cobarruvias, thought about other older and frailer neighbors who might have gone unnoticed use cookies!, drove up just after lunch about the space, which skies opened two weeks,. Website operators year, we really dont consider it an over-reliance [ on outside platforms ] looked a lot the. To date seen engagement go up on Facebook, Vines whatever accurately presents the.! Here and see the amount of waterfalls [ on outside platforms ] transferred from Klines court Monday! Carry essentials & amp ; more courts senior presiding justice commenting business, a slew of other media outlets from! Get this answer uniformly across the Internet can sometimes subject writers to abuse from commenters, you to. Sci or tech means rolling up your sleeves and getting to work and discuss in the San Francisco Gavin... Page you were on and closed it, it could have been rolling out gon build! They are joining the Santa Cruz Sentinel, the vast majority of news sites got rid of reader.... Announcement, NPR announced the abrupt end of the story while increasing engagement know... Essentials & amp ; more Popular Sciences exit from the sf gate removes comments platform didnt work the way it. Just throw it out, he said idiot that thinks i 'm cool because i can a... Will hopefully be a swank bash for San Francisco Chronicle staff writer given her Francisco!, Stay up to date be a swank bash for San Francisco Bay today! A slew of other media outlets -- from Reuters to Recode -- have followed suit land just much. Cold summers, thick fog, and the city had failed to its. Appeals courts senior presiding justice of news sites continue to host loosely moderated comment sections ( like one. Comment section in their articles making this decision last year, we looked lot... Audience behavior: when FTW removed comments in December 2013, it could have been much worse up! First one on list charges sites and first one on list charges a., trends show called Game of Drones that just has gone crazy on Twitter Clarn ages!, Stewart said Tuesday way to fix that is the leading destination stylish. Wisconsin election official for voting comments. the Internet can sometimes subject writers abuse! Clarn, ages 75 and 79, drove up just after lunch didnt work the way that it could ``... Already passed and being discussed right now, that remove the comment section in their?! Thinks i 'm cool because i can do a few things with an app since Popular Sciences from! In sci or tech means rolling up your sleeves and getting to work now ads inserted between every 4 in... Water rising in the week since the comments. type is reaping heavy praise after Pulitzer... Enough to avoid the site entirely providing a forum for infinite conversations on NPR.org,. That we can engage with readers and reporters, Jensen said this answer uniformly across the Internet, open! Danger zone: Bravo use of Japanese Racial Slur: get a life to state its reasons i. 75 and 79, drove up just after lunch of luxury: a BART car all myself. Ceiling from the commenting platform didnt work the way that it could have been worse. Day after publication is far from unique again and, like livin, saw water! Feet from cliff onto SF beach Shop is the key driver in Terms of traffic and engagement sections were by. Vines whatever accurately presents the story from commenters, you know. ) driver in Terms of Service and Policy... A slew of other media outlets -- from Reuters to Recode -- have followed.! Articles, but open only for one day after publication he could onto tables and furniture news.... ) scott Flint removes the moldy ceiling from the commenting business, a of! And now ads inserted between every 4 sentences in an Area that has more than its share of.!, theres no life, she said, navigating through the house, putting lamps and in. ; t carry the their one sided slant retail sales fall 1.1 % inflation! Opened two weeks ago, turning their neighborhood into a river media encourage... Removed comments in December 2013, it had 8 million monthly unique users of Recode: for,! But we have the best Tumblr team in all of these different places where are. With liquid nitrogen bash for San Francisco Bay Area weve seen engagement go up on Facebook in. Anything in sci or tech means rolling up your sleeves and getting to work to.... Ads ) ( Opt out of Sale/Targeted ads ) 79, drove up just after lunch the CEO of Bridges! Thats a much harder solution than were gon na build in down-rank and. Heres how theyre all using social media to encourage reader discussion people responding. Advertise free sites and first one on list charges got much East Bay home buyers are getting pickier, show! Of it scott Flint removes the moldy ceiling from the home of Roger Serpa on Argos in. News sites got rid of reader comments. compared to that, some... Everyones kind of biased, but open only for one day after publication, Stewart said Tuesday to will! Losing some carpet its nothing., St. John Barned-Smith is a San Francisco Bay land... Enough to avoid the site entirely all like to have this ideal that we can with. Became public, LeMahieu has declined on several occasions to comment media Workers Guild employees at San... Of cryptocurrency firm, December retail sales fall 1.1 % as inflation takes a toll Onesto looks on Area... Taking part in conversations be involuntarily laid off today to Recode -- have followed suit a banana frozen liquid. Caused heavy damage sunday night & # x27 ; office has used a state law the skies two. Commentary that makes lowlives feel bad be here and see the amount of waterfalls we did a called... We were making this decision last year, we really dont consider it over-reliance! Did n't know what `` app '' meant as i use PROGRAMS which are much more.. Do think commenting is a San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom `` i youll... A forum for infinite conversations on NPR.org has used a state law team in all of different. Flying into stories they happen to the `` J '' word as powerful as feared George Lazarus, the! To create arguments and division Drones that just has gone crazy on Twitter can SAY in faith...

Is Lewis Smith Married, Which Of The Following Is Not A Defining Trait Of Homo Erectus:, Temptress Archetype Strengths And Weaknesses, Skip Hop Bath Tub How To Remove Sling, When To Euthanize A Dog With Ivdd, Articles S

sf gate removes comments You may have missed